The systemic investigation calls for emergency protection orders, stable shelter funding, and a confidential 24-hour reporting service. The Ministry of Justice did not respond to the preliminary findings by the deadline.
PHILIPSBURG:--- Survivors of domestic abuse in Sint Maarten described delayed emergency responses, dismissive treatment, and breaches of confidentiality, while children exposed to abuse can face barriers to counseling and protection, according to a November 2026 report by the Ombudsman. The investigation found that gaps in the law, inconsistent referrals, and unstable funding leave survivors and children without adequate protection.
The Ombudsman opened the investigation after receiving several complaints in late 2024 and early 2025. Most involved children who were directly targeted or exposed to abuse. Investigators examined the response of the ministries responsible for justice, public health and social development, and education and youth affairs.
A domestic abuse policy was reportedly signed, but the Ombudsman found it had not yet been published and its status remained unclear. Agencies largely worked within their own mandates, leaving gaps in referrals and follow-up and uncertainty over who should take the lead. Inconsistent recordkeeping also made it impossible to establish a reliable overview of cases and outcomes.
Survivors face barriers when seeking safety
The report found that visible physical harm often determined whether survivors received protection. Threats, intimidation, financial abuse, and patterns of coercive control received insufficient attention, including when abuse continued after separation through custody or visitation arrangements.
Safe Haven requires a police or medical report for admission. The Ombudsman found that funding cuts had reduced its capacity and that the transitional shelter had closed. Survivors also faced barriers to leaving an abusive home, including financial dependence, limited housing, difficulty accessing legal aid, and immigration status tied to a partner or guarantor.
The Ombudsman called for multi-year funding for Safe Haven and Victim Support Services and a review of shelter admission rules so survivors can receive urgent protection while documentation is being arranged. The report also recommends assessing the need for accommodation for male survivors and people with disabilities or complex care needs.
Children need their own route to protection
The investigation found that children exposed to domestic abuse were too often overlooked as people with protection needs of their own. Access to counseling could depend on consent from a parent whose conduct was part of the concern. The report also flagged a lack of feedback from the Court of Guardianship to referring institutions and found that children had no independent complaints mechanism.
The Ombudsman recommended establishing a Children’s Ombudsman and requiring written procedures for assessing threats, coercive control, and children’s exposure to abuse in custody and visitation cases. The report also called for safe handovers and supervised contact where appropriate, independent inspections of foster and residential care, and stronger support for young people leaving care or detention.
Justice Ministry did not respond to preliminary findings
The Ombudsman recommended a published, funded government-wide policy that assigns responsibility at every stage of a case. It also urged the government to consider legislation allowing emergency orders to temporarily remove an abusive person from the home and civil protection orders that survivors could request from the court.
Other proposals include a free, confidential, multilingual 24-hour reporting and advice service, clearer procedures for survivors seeking independent residence status, and formal arrangements with French Saint Martin for emergency assistance, referrals, and cross-border custody and protection cases. The report also calls for consistent data collection and regular public reporting so the government can track delays and measure whether reforms improve protection.
The Ombudsman sent the preliminary findings to the ministers of Justice, Public Health, Social Development and Labor, and Education, Culture, Youth and Sport on October 30, with responses due November 16. The health and education ministries submitted responses on time. The Ombudsman said it received no response from the Minister of Justice. The report says the responsible ministers must inform the Ombudsman whether and how they have acted on the recommendations and explain any decision to reject or modify them.







