St. Martin News Network

Saturday
Feb 04th
Text size
  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size
Home St. Maarten - St. Martin News SEVERAL QUESTIONS SURROUNDING MYSTERIOUS DEATH OF 11 YEAR OLD--- MOTHER’S WORST NIGHTMARE is not knowing what Killed him.

SEVERAL QUESTIONS SURROUNDING MYSTERIOUS DEATH OF 11 YEAR OLD--- MOTHER’S WORST NIGHTMARE is not knowing what Killed him.

E-mail Print PDF
User Rating: / 2
PoorBest 
oliver21122009Sandy Ground: -- The parents, relatives, teachers, and students of Sandy Ground Primary all have questions that are yet to be answered about the sudden death of 11-year-old Olivier Laurence Simon.
His mother Catherine Simon in an interview with SMN News said her son fell ill on November 27 2009. Simon said her son told her he ate something in school that day and he began having belly pains and was feeling extremely tired. Simon said she told her son to take a nap since he also played football that day. The next morning she said Olivier woke up with a fever and was vomiting. She said she took him to see a doctor located at the Marina Fort Royale and this doctor told her the child had dengue and he gave her a prescription to buy some medication. The mother said she was amazed at the diagnosis because the doctor never conducted any blood test but he determined that the child had dengue based on the symptoms. The mother said the doctor also gave her a letter to take to the Sandy Ground Primary School where the child is a student. "I am not a doctor so I did what the doctor told me and now my son is dead."

Simon said the child never got better instead his condition worsened and she then took him to the emergency room at the Louis Constant Fleming Hospital on December 3 where the doctors also determined the child had dengue without conducting the necessary testing. She said at the hospital the doctor on duty gave the child some syrup and told her that she has to allow the medication given to her by the city doctor and the syrup he prescribed to work, since there is actually no medication for dengue.

simon21122009Simon said her son was sent home on that day but the moment she left the hospital her son began telling her that the syrup that was given to him is scratching his mouth and inside of his stomach. She said despite that she bought the syrup and continued giving her son the medication that was prescribed to him but on December 9 the child collapsed.

Simon said she took the child back to the hospital because by then the child was vomiting blood. She said it was then the doctors at the Louis Constant Fleming Hospital decided to admit the child and to conduct the necessary tests. "It was after they took a test they came to tell me that my son does not have dengue. Instead, he has a terrible infection and germ that has attacked his organs. The doctor said the infection already attacked his heart and lungs, but up to now no one can say what type of infection Olivier had." 'They told me the blood he was vomiting was coming from his throat but that too turned out to be false."
The distraught mother said she sat beside her son bedside and saw that the doctors at the Louis Constant Fleming Hospital did not know what they were treating her son for and she even asked them to send the child to either Martinique or Guadeloupe where the doctors would be better equipped to diagnose her son's illness. She said the doctors told her that the same medication that is given to Olivier on St. Martin would be given to him elsewhere and that he would get better with time. On December 15, Simon said she left the hospital to go to her job since she did not report to work since the child got ill. She said shortly after she received a call and was told that she needed to return to the hospital immediately since her son needed blood and she needed to sign for him to get that blood. Simon said the doctor assured her that when the child is transfused he would get better. The woman said she signed the form and the minute the child got the blood his condition deteriorated. "My son was vomiting the blood they gave him. They gave him two bags of blood and he began vomiting it right away." She said she looked at her son and saw how he was breathing and she knew that he was dying. "It was then several doctors came including nurses and began working on my son as they prepare to ship him out to Martinique for further treatment." Simon said her child died as he was on his way to that island, and to date no doctor at the Louis Constant Fleming Hospital can say what killed him.
"The doctors want me to stay quiet but I cannot, I need to know what killed my son and who is responsible for his death."

Bringing the Body Back to St. Martin.

Simon said when her son died the hospital called her and the doctors wanted to know what she is going to do now that he is dead. She said she met with a social worker who told her they could arrange for the child to be cremated in Martinique and the ashes can be brought back to St. Martin, which she refused. Catherine Simon a national of Dominica said the Social Worker told her she had no rights to contest or fight to bring the body of her son back to St. Martin since she has been residing on St. Martin illegally. Simons said ever since she has been raising funds to pay for her son's body to be returned to St. Martin, where he was born and went to school so that he can have a decent funeral, she said she also met with the prosecutor where she outlined her case.
In an invited comment, Vice Prosecutor Jacques Louvier said he did receive the parent and has ordered an autopsy. The autopsy he said should be conducted sometime this week in Martinique.

The fight to Obtain Residency.

impot22122009Catherine Simon said she has been trying to obtain a Carte de Sejour for years but she has been denied. The woman said she arrived on St. Martin in the year 1996 with a French visa. Since then she has been working, and declaring her taxes. Catherine Simon also has an indefinite working contract along with social security.
However, for unknown reasons her application for residency on the French side has been denied on several occasions. She was asked to leave St. Martin which she tried doing but her island Dominica has refused to accept Olivier Laurence Simon since he was born on St. Martin and was not in possession of a travel document. Simon said she was forced to return to St. Martin with her son and ever since then she has been residing and working on the French side with an indefinite working contract.
The woman said when her son died the social worker contacted the Prefecture to see if they could grant her a lesser passer (travel permit) to go over to Martinique to arrange her son autopsy and that too was denied. She said after insistence the prefecture had decided to give her authorization for one day but that was not enough.
workcontract21122009Catherine Simon is now calling on the prefecture to tell her what she has done to St. Martin or those responsible for the granting of residency for them to deny her. She said even her son who was born on the island did not have any documents even though he was attending school.
The child she said once asked her if he was not from St. Martin and Dominica where is he from since he was supposed to travel with his school to Guadeloupe. The woman said a teacher from that school fought for her child to go along with his class, which he did not long before he died. Furthermore, Simon has a daughter who has completed school on the French side and the prefecture also denied her residency. "Someone at the prefecture told my 18 year old daughter that the only way she can get her papers is if she bore a child for someone from St. Martin."

payslip21122009In an invited comment, Monsieur Nicoli said that he was at his office from 7 am to grant the Simon a one-day permit to travel to Martinique to cremate her son but no one ever went to pick up the document. Nicoli said the assistant social from the hospital made the arrangements for him to be at his office at 7 am and no one ever contacted him after to say they were not interested in the one-day permit. Furthermore, asked why Simon could not have her documents Nicoli said that he did not have any dossier for the woman. He said people have to respect the law when applying for French residency, which includes the speaking of the French language.

 

feed26 Comments
Sandy
December, 21, 2009, 12:43
200.7.52.24
Votes: +3

this is what i dont understand

The people that are contributing by payin taxes etc are having a hard time obtaining legal residency!!!

yet,those are just here to make a profit n live off the goverment are obtaining their papers ez

By strong,dear mother, truth will come out just keep pushing u have a right to give ur child a proper funeral!!

report abuse
vote down
vote up
so sad
December, 21, 2009, 12:54
72.252.13.172
Votes: +3

It is so sad that a mother have to see her child die and even then no compa*sion was sown to help her. I hope and pray for Gods loving kindness to help her through her sadness.

may his souls rest in P

report abuse
vote down
vote up
trouble start
December, 21, 2009, 13:07
200.7.48.74
Votes: +2

what happen to the father he illegal to.the french government ain't playing no games even st martin people getting trouble to renew their paper works.a lot of france people in office in marigot now and they don't give a dam .no french who next.

report abuse
vote down
vote up
amen
December, 21, 2009, 14:13
200.7.51.54
Votes: +4

if the child had a germ and a infection then the child had meningitis. that disease does attack the organs fast. You have to catch it in time to stop the infection from spreading thru the rest of the organs. Once it reach the lungs it over . The person eventually dies. My aunt die from that right here. The mother should have never continue giving him the meds. The wrong meds help it to spread faster. It depends which one he had also. there is meningitis 1 and meningitis 2. One u don't die from and one you do. I can't recall which one. She have to look up a medical dictionary. MY aunt took ill Monday and she die the Friday and they give her syrup also. But she went to the doctor on the dutch side. If the doctor had figure out which one he had they could have help him or tell her to prepare. It a bacteria actually that comes from dirty water or unclean toilets. If someone have it and they sneeze or breath in your face or if u use anything like dishes or clothing of that person u can also come infected. If that what he had and it sounds like that to me then they have to check the other children to see ho he got it and who else infected. My aunt was in pain it was just eating her inside and the doctors on the dutch side did not know what was wrong with her. They give her a injection because she was screaming my heart my heart and after they give her the injection she went in a coma. They send her curacao . The doctor in curacao that find out that she had meningitis and the quarantine the place but they couldn't help her because they told us the infection had already reach the lungs the heart and attacking the brain. smilies/angry.gif

report abuse
vote down
vote up
buffy
December, 21, 2009, 15:26
208.91.192.28
Votes: +1

am so sorry mis simon,god is by your side,just pray an your pray will answer,i have to of mine owne,an that so said

report abuse
vote down
vote up
Keep the faith
December, 21, 2009, 18:47
200.7.61.74
Votes: +1

Catherine, keep the faith. Its almost 2 years now you were confronted with the sudden death of your sister in law. You did all the running aroung, putting stuff together for her home going, today its your son. You are a good person at heart and GOD will see you through all of this.

Keep the faith,

report abuse
vote down
vote up
drama for your mama
December, 22, 2009, 01:49
193.158.86.101
Votes: +1

so sad to hear wa happen, these damn ppl can't help the woman they ain see she greaving? Look how long she déclaring and paying taxes... the minimum is to help her i think we should manifeste cause alot of shizzle going on that ain fair.... chuppppppssssss keep your head up madame Simone our prayers are with you

report abuse
vote down
vote up
my 2 cents
December, 22, 2009, 03:16
200.7.52.65
Votes: +0

it is sad to read what has happened. But in my opinion the child has pa*sed away. May his soul rest in peace. Lady sorry for your loss, but now it is time for you to follow the law of our country, pack your goergey bundle and GO HOME. If we break the law for you, because of the situation, then we have to break it for someone else, and then in the end we will still be here complaining about illegals. Your country stuck by their laws, so we have to stick by ours. I know it is harsh, but face reality, don,t ask us to bend our rules, when your own country don't have sympathy to bend theirs.

report abuse
vote down
vote up
shamefull
December, 22, 2009, 04:17
195.132.220.184
Votes: +1

it's is very shamefull the C.O.M put money to pay for an guadeloupe woman court case, & ain't trying to help this woman who child is a born st-martiner (even if his mom from dominca) the momther should go & talk to the president & hear what he stories will be

report abuse
vote down
vote up
psn
December, 22, 2009, 04:20
92.160.127.184
Votes: +0

My condolances to you for the pa*sing of yor son. Because the child is not under social security, they did not do go to the extreme because somebody got to pay for the extra the blood tests. It is not fair but the hospital already suffering loses so they strick on that. Also, declaring your income do not entitle anyone to automatically get their papers fixed because declaring income does not mean she is paying taxes. By the figures i see above, she was not be paying taxes (low income with children). Also, to get your papers fixed, your indefinite contract need to be full time, and by what i see above, you are working (or declared) part time. A lot of discrepencies here to explain why your request was refused. It is only when your duaghter reach 18 i think that she can apply for her papers if she can prove she was born and schooled here for the 18 years. i know also that the boy mother should applied for a dominican pa*sport for him, he would got it because all dominicans here getting there dominican pa*sport renewed without a problem; even if he born here, once you got a dominican parents (mother in this case) he would get it, and Dominica would not turn him back from going there, that part is not very true.
As "my 2 cents" says the law is the law, and it is sad that your son had to pay the penalty for parents decision. some illegals on the island who don't got their papers refusing to go back to their country where they can be legal and at home, they staying here putting there life and child life on hold, language barrier, but still staying here. and sometimes they children living in unhumane conditions which could cause all kind of germs and infections to affect the little ones.
i pray that you get this sorted Catherine, and even think over the situation, losing your son is not worth any papers or money. God bless and keep you in this diffucult time.

report abuse
vote down
vote up
CRAZY TILL THE LAST DAYS
December, 22, 2009, 05:20
200.7.57.77
Votes: +0

THANK YOU MY 2 CENT COULD'N HAVE BEEN SAID ANY BETTER .THERE OWN DON'T WAN'T THEM NO PROBLEM BUT ST MAARTEN MUST BE RESPONSIBLE FOR EVERY ONE WHAT A SHAME LAW AND NO ORDER. MAY HIS SOUL REST IN PEACE.

report abuse
vote down
vote up
Give jack his jacket
December, 22, 2009, 05:56
200.7.37.106
Votes: +5

Hey the bible in right in the last days people hearts will grow wax cold, I don't agree with those that come sit dow do all kind of crime at night and have all the luxury of living here free, but this lady is contributing she paying her dews the tax of the land, if she aint good to give papers, then let her work tax free, at this moment in her life she don't want to be redicule for breaking law of the land, and she didn't asked for the rules to be bend she simple doing her part and like any good citizen she want's to be reward legally,seeing she's here so long she could have pay under the table but she going to the relevant people in order to abtain is status legally.
May God comfort you in your time of sorrow.

report abuse
vote down
vote up
weather
December, 22, 2009, 07:08
190.185.59.47
Votes: +2

i find it really strange.... that dominica refused to accept her son

i'm in bit of a doubt.....

report abuse
vote down
vote up
Simple Explanation
December, 22, 2009, 07:13
200.7.54.53
Votes: +0

Well, it is somewhat true that you can apply for a pa*sport for your child when u are from Dominica but I'm sure u would need some sort of documents for her son. Do you really believe she had them?? If she did do u think she could leave SXM and they would let her come back so easy?? Her job goin give her the time off?? Who goin watch her children when she gone??......Watch a person's circumstances before u open ur mouth or have doubts....

report abuse
vote down
vote up
lizette
December, 22, 2009, 08:22
76.122.12.202
Votes: +0

why was the sent to martinique,guadeloupe closer to s.m than guadeloupe.i can't stop crying,this story hurts my heart to the core.it is soo sad how a stupid piece of paper for residency can cause someone to loose their child.someone should be held responsible for this.people need to learn to RESPECT other people regradless of nationality.even here in new york at the french consulate they are very rude,although i was born in guadeloupe and have a french pa*sport they still talk to you like sh*t.someone should write to the french president and complain.GET ALL THEIR A**ES IN TROUBLE. A CHILD CANNOT BE REPLACED.

report abuse
vote down
vote up
2 CENTS U WRONG!
December, 22, 2009, 16:24
67.80.229.236
Votes: +4

This is for "MY 2 CENTS"....U r simply a Jack a** no other way of putting it. Pray ur a** or nobody in ur family ends up in a situation similar!! We never know where we will fall, and we all looking for ways to survive and provide for our family, the woman is hard working and paying taxes she ain't gettin sh**t for free!
This was no ordinary situtation, her son Died as a result, in circumstances when lives are at stake and lost, its OKAY for rules to be bent! So don't say "its sad what happened and may his soul rest in peace" clearly heart felt condolences is not on ur agenda and u r incapable of feeling!
You're a Cold hearted B!!

report abuse
vote down
vote up
SXMTINER
December, 22, 2009, 17:27
208.78.49.171
Votes: +3

I AM SO ASHAME OF THIS STORY. I DONT CARE IF SHE IS DOMINICAN OR NOT, SHE AND HER SON ARE HULAN. FRANCE BOST ABOUT LE DROIT DE L ENFANT THE RIGHTS OF THE CHILD, BUT YET LOOK AT HOW SXM TREATING THIS WOMAN AND HOW THEY TREAT HER SON. I AM FROM SXM AND I DONT CARE WRONG IS WRONG. IF THEY DIDNT KNOW WHAT WAS WRONG WITH THE CHILD, THEY SHOULD AVE TAKEN A BLOOD TEST TO KNOW. HE IS NOT AND WASNT ANY GUINEA PIG TO BE EXPERIMENTING MEDICATION ON. I PRAY THAT JUSTICVE WILL BE SERVE. ENOUGH IS ENOUGH. NO MATTER WHAT COLOUR, CREED, NATIONALITY WE ARE ALL HUMANS AND SHOULD BE TREATED AS SUCH. I DIDNT EVEN READ THE COMMENTS. I JUST WNATED TO SAY, THIS IS WRONG AND MY HEART GO OUT TO HER AND MAY GOD STRENGHTEN HER I THIS TIME. IF THERE IS SOME FOR OF DONATION I AM WILLING T CONTRIBUTE WHAT EVER LIL I CAN. WE ALL NEED EACH OTHER

report abuse
vote down
vote up
Keep the faith
December, 22, 2009, 19:31
200.7.61.100
Votes: +1

Keep the faith sister. To 2 cents, you eh worth a farthing muchless for 2 cents. You are sooooo inhumane. I pray that nothing happens to you or your family. We are all GODS children, legal or illegal.

report abuse
vote down
vote up
sad story but
December, 22, 2009, 20:58
92.160.95.26
Votes: +0

how anybody know for sure she was paying taxes? watch the amounts good, she was NOT eligible to pay taxes because of low income children to support. so stop speaking of her paying dues. Also you do not have to travel to dominica to get a dominica pa*sport, you can send your documents by fedex with the return paid for and they will send the pa*sport back to you. the rule is that you have to be working full time to get your documents fix (with other conditions), her pay slip show she working part time. also they send the child martinique because that where the heart facility is.

report abuse
vote down
vote up
my 2 cents
December, 23, 2009, 04:37
200.7.52.119
Votes: +0

to all of u, who have made comments, whenever the situation involves death we always get extremely emotional. To each is entitled their opinion. I am just saying we have to learn to abide by our laws whether it be my country ST.Martin, where I was borned and raised or a foreign country to where i do not belong. WE HAVE TO ABIDE BY RULES, WE HAVE TO ABIDE BY LAWS, WE HAVE TO STOP TRYING TO HAVE IT OUR WAY.If we continue to always make an exception we will continue to live in a cowboy, wild wild west country. I am human, I have experienced death, when my brother died in guadeloupe, we paid for him to come back, and because of his illnes we were given RULES and LAWS that we could not open his coffin. So up 2 today we don't know if we buried a log. So i do know death, but whenever the facts are stated it hurts the most. But like I said we are all human and entitled to our opinions and emotions. May the little boy's soul rest in peace, but I like to abide by the law. Death is never easy, once it is all over, what will you do continue to fight for papers? WHY? If you have been denied so much why do you still want to stay in our country? tell me? Lastly if you all know God, you would know that when death comes, one should rejoice and not behave the way you all react.

report abuse
vote down
vote up
FOR THE KIDS SAKE
December, 23, 2009, 05:14
200.7.56.206
Votes: +0

LISTEN TO ME I AM A MAN AND DOES USED MY WAYS TO DO THINGS THE RIGHT WAY OTHER WISE YOU PAY THE PRICE.IF ONE MY KID IS SICK IT'S MY DUTIE TO ASK THE DOCTOR TO DO A BLOOD TEST ON MY DEMAND I JUST DID IT LATELY HEAR AND THE PROBLEM WAS SERVE RIGHT AWAY .SO PEOPLE DON'T ANY DOCTOR TAKE YOU FOR A RIDE IN HIS FEVOR .BLOOD TEST DON'T LIE AND IT'S FAST SO PEOPLE DO THE RIGHT THING AND DEMAND FOR A BLOOD TEST AND YOU BE MORE THAN HAPPY WITH THE OUT COME .SO MOTHERS OUT THERE TAKE MY ADVISE AND TRY TO AVOID THESE SITUATION. MERRY CHRISTMAS TO ALL ON BOARD.THINK SMART.

report abuse
vote down
vote up
Attitude change
December, 23, 2009, 08:23
72.252.9.55
Votes: +0

Sometimes you are left feeling unsure of the situation. Here is your child, sicker than a dog, here is an "educated man" who should know more than you. Your gut is telling you that there is something else that can/should be done, but what? Mothers who were ever confronted with a similar situation would feel what the mother went through. Doctors please do a better job in taking care of the sick because when you leave the family members are left holding that person and feeling helpless. Who would have paid for the blood test? Anybody who knew of the severity would have pitched in to help. If you do not know, you can not help, so tell it , let someone else know.

report abuse
vote down
vote up
mommabear
December, 23, 2009, 11:52
99.231.104.222
Votes: +1

Kudos to St. Martin Island News for reporting this truly tragic event. It is responsible reporting, as people should be made aware about situations like this -- the death of a previously healthy young boy as the result of an obviously lethal disease/condition that was never diagnosed and consequently, left virtually untreated. Surely, cause of death needs to be determined to ensure, as best as possible, that it doesn't happen again! This information must be obtained for public health and safety and to meet the standard of good medical practice. Every physician, whether Dutch-side or French-side, takes an Oath to above all do no harm. To bury or cremate this child without determining what disease process caused his death could do a great deal of harm indeed!

report abuse
vote down
vote up
WENDY
December, 23, 2009, 17:08
69.127.42.213
Votes: +0

THIS IS JUST A PITY THAT PEOPLE HAVE TO SUFFER SUCH INDIGNITY EVEN IN DEATH MY GOD HER SON WAS BORN IN ST MARTIN ,PLEASE LET HER BURY HIM IN PEACE, THEN DEAL WITH THE OTHER MATTER LATER

report abuse
vote down
vote up
Enough
December, 23, 2009, 17:42
90.63.151.30
Votes: +0

SOME PEOPLE NEVER WORK BUT COLLECTING MONEY FOR WHAT ? JUST TO BREED AND THEY GIVING THEM PAPERS THIS UNJUSTICE HAS TO STOP. SEND THOSE BREEDERS BACK THEY JUST GETTING ALL OF OUR TAX MONEY THAT THEY SENDING OUT BY WESTERN UNION (DUTCH SIDE NOT EVEN FRENCH SIDE). COME ON? STOP THIS BULLSH*T

report abuse
vote down
vote up
SICK OF THEM
December, 25, 2009, 10:34
92.160.126.102
Votes: +0

the caf breaders they have cmu papers everthing but this woman working paying taxes is denied just wonder why they r encouraging this caff breaders???????

report abuse
vote down
vote up

Write comment
This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comment.

busy
Last Updated ( Tuesday, 22 December 2009 16:03 )